Book Review
Gliff (2025)
by Ali Smith
I try to keep up with Scottish author Ali Smith. She is both highly regarded in the literary world, with a slew of Booker shortlisting's (2001, 2005, 2014 and 2016) and shelf full with minor literary awards. Smith is prolific for a writer of literary fiction, averaging a new book every couple of years. I skipped her four volume cycle about the seasons- my least favorite literary motif, it slightly clips "the difficulties of young motherhood" in that department. I did, however, pick-up Gliff, her latest, since it promised a post-apocalyptic milieu (yay!) seen through the eyes of a child (sigh). The 1,001 Novels: A Library of America has pumped so full of YA lit and adult books written from the perspective of a child that I've developed a cogent body of criticisms regarding these books and their motifs.
Specifically, these books (YA books and those adult books written from the perspective of children) feature narrators and protagonists who can't go anywhere and can't do anything, and most every book that fits this description involves a child or "young adult" who is stuck somewhere and can't do anything about it but wants to "get out." The book is then about whether they escape their sad surroundings or fail to do so and why.
Gliff fits this description- the characters are a pair of siblings, the protagonist is the elder sibling, a boy, who have been rendered "unverifiable"- the dystopian/novel equivalent of being an illegal alien in this future.. England? Scotland? Unverifiability has nothing to do with race or immigration status, but seems to have been applied to everyone who broadly disagrees with the current government. Unlike most YA titles, the language in Gliff is interesting- I found myself looking up words and phrases online, trying to make sense of what Smith was talking about. At least, in this way, Smith has created a work far different than the usual simple-minded YA dystopian tropes. However, in another, more important (for this reader anyway) Smith has done nothing unusual in her plotting, which made me wonder whether she is trying for some kind of commercial success with Gliff- a book for the punters, in her mind, perhaps.
Having read the book, I don't know.