Dear Martin (2017) by Nic Stone

 1,001 Novels: A Library of America

Dear Martin (2017)

by Nic Stone

Westbrook Academy, 

401 Lewis Braselton Road, Atlanta, Georgia

Georgia: 2/26

   Dear Martin is another YA title, by far my least favorite category in the 1,001 Novels: A Library of America list.   This book is a good example of what I find so unlikeable about the whole category:  It's a book about a African-American high school student who is on scholarship at a prestigious Atlanta-area boarding school.   He has to deal with normal prep school kid stuff, then about 100 pages in, his best friend gets shot by an off-duty cop at a traffic intersection.  Then, of course, you get another hundred pages of him dealing with his emotions about the shooting.

 Despite this extremely adult subject, the rest of the book is written like the author is trying to PROTECT her audience from every other adult subject.  I.E.: Not one curse word, not one act of adult sexuality beyond holding hands and light kissing and no violence.  If you are going to write a novel about a teen being murdered in cold blood by an off-duty cop, doesn't the audience deserve the rest of adulthood?  According to the conventions of YA fiction, they do not.  Thus, it is a universe of books about rape without any sex, about murder without any violence and about complex emotions without complex characters.